The September QI Update
Court Rejects Qualified Immunity in Louisiana Traffic Stop Case
After nearly four years of fighting for accountability, Mario Rosales and Gracie Lasyone can move forward with their lawsuit over an unconstitutional traffic stop. The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected the officers’ qualified immunity claims. This is the third court ruling denying the officers that shield from liability. Mario and Gracie are represented by the Institute for Justice, the nonprofit law firm behind the AAQI initiative. Their case illustrates how qualified immunity can delay justice, even when courts repeatedly reject it.
QI in the Courts
Each week, IJ’s Center for Judicial Engagement publishes a newsletter highlighting opinions by the Federal Courts, aptly called Short Circuit (it’s also a podcast ). AAQI highlights the QI-related stories from Short Circuit each month in our monthly email series: QI in the Courts. If you have not already, you can subscribe to the newsletter here to get the full list of opinion summaries each week.
September 11th Newsletter
- North Carolina prison officers keep woman shackled during active labor, as well as at other times before, during, and after giving birth. District court: Qualified immunity. Fourth Circuit : Vacated. No security or flight risk = an Eighth Amendment violation, as was discontinuing her opioid-withdrawal meds after she’d given birth. A jury must determine whether some of the defendants acted with deliberate indifference.
- Allegation: Jackson, Miss. officials knew that the city’s lead-contaminated drinking water was unsafe and told residents otherwise. A former mayor even scrapped planned upgrades. Can the city and its officials be sued for violating residents’ right to bodily integrity? Fifth Circuit (2025): The city but not the officials. Fifth Circuit (en banc, 2026): Neither the city nor the officials. Dissent: Plaintiffs also advanced a plausible state-created-danger theory; we should have joined the ten other circuits that recognize that theory (and then granted qualified immunity because it wasn’t clearly established).
- Two internal candidates, who are both white guys, complete application process to become the new police commish, but the mayor reopens the search, saying, “St. Louis is more diverse than white males, our police department is more diverse.” ( The city eventually hires Wilmington, Del.’s erstwhile chief, a white male, for the position.) Eighth Circuit : Maybe an equal protection violation. To discovery this must go. No qualified immunity.
- Allegation: It’s easy for inmates at Columbia County, Ark. jail to break out of their pod; they just wedge clothes between the door and frame. They do this for months, and eventually attack a pretrial detainee housed in a different pod, causing a serious head injury. Eighth Circuit (per curiam): Qualified immunity.
- Allegation: Miami-Dade officers corner suspect after armed robbery and dangerous high-speed chase. He does not resist as officers drag him from his truck. They beat him blind: He suffers 25 facial fractures, an eye pops out of its socket, his skull is caved in. Other inmates now call him “The Martian” on account of his deformities. Jury: It was not excessive force to beat him after he stopped resisting. Eleventh Circuit (unpublished): And qualified immunity for beating him when he was resisting. Dissent: What resisting?!
- Allegation: Florida prisoner suffers serious head injury after being struck by flying 50 lb. chunk of concrete at St. Lucie County job site. County employee operating backhoe: That did not happen. District court : Let’s find out! No qualified immunity. Eleventh Circuit (unpublished): Reversed. Qualified immunity. Special concurrence: It’s a tort, not a constitutional violation.
September 18th Newsletter
- The Third Circuit giveth: Henceforth, the Fourth Amendment generally requires a warrant supported by probable cause to strip search an arrestee (deepening a circuit split). The Third Circuit taketh away: But qualified immunity in this case.
- Allegation : Woman calls Tampa, Fla. police to report a suspicious man with a gun near her apartment. Officers don’t locate him, and when they knock on the woman’s door, her dog slips out and runs at an officer, who shoots it in the head. (It lives.) She tries to take the dog to the vet, but officers stop her. Eleventh Circuit (unpublished): Which was very possibly an unreasonable seizure. But QI. There’s no prior case saying it’s unreasonable to detain a witness to a shooting for 12 minutes.
September 25th Newsletter
- Maryland appeals court (2016): It was unconstitutional for Baltimore police to use a cell-site simulator without a warrant to locate this shooting suspect. Suppress the evidence. Fourth Circuit (2026): It was unconstitutional, and we have concerns about law enforcement relying on private nondisclosure agreements “as an excuse to conceal or obfuscate important information when seeking a search warrant.” But qualified immunity, state-law “public official” immunity, and municipal immunity doom his claims for damages for the nearly two years spent in pretrial detention.
- It’s beyond debate that officers cannot pull someone over without reasonable suspicion and then invent a bogus reason for the stop afterwards, says the Fifth Circuit (per curiam, unpublished). So this case about Alexandria, La. officers who said a motorist failed to signal despite dashcam footage showing otherwise (and who then unlawfully prolonged the stop) will proceed past the pleading stages (nearly four years and over 200 docket entries after it was filed). No qualified immunity. ( This is an IJ case .)
- Indiana man gets life for gun and drug crimes, but wait! His sentence was enhanced because of some threatening text messages (that the jury didn’t see) discovered by dint of a warrantless forensic examination of his phone. Seventh Circuit (unpublished): Qualified immunity. It’s not clearly established that if the examining officer is told there’s a warrant, and there isn’t, that that’s an unconstitutional search.
The August QI Update
Follow Americans Against Qualified Immunity!
Stay connected and join the fight for government accountability! Follow us on Facebook at Americans Against Qualified Immunity , on Instagram at @americansagainstqi , and on X at @USAgainstQI .
QI in the Courts
Each week, IJ’s Center for Judicial Engagement publishes a newsletter highlighting opinions by the Federal Courts, aptly called Short Circuit (it’s also a podcast ). AAQI highlights the QI-related stories from Short Circuit each month in our monthly email series: QI in the Courts. If you have not already, you can subscribe to the newsletter here to get the full list of opinion summaries each week.
August 7th Newsletter
- Qualified Immunity Victory! In April 2024, North Carolina sheriff’s deputies looking for a suspected thief conducted a terrifying midnight raid on the home of Avery Marshall and Alisa Carr, holding the couple’s two children at gunpoint and trashing the house. But the warrant to search Avery and Alisa’s home was based on false testimony, and police continued to ransack the place even after it became clear they were in the wrong house (the actual suspect was apprehended the next day in a different county). This week, a district judge denied the officers’ qualified immunity argument and allowed the case to move forward. Click here for more information.
August 14th Newsletter
- In Texas, arrestees may request appointed counsel at their first appearance, after which the magistrate must transmit, or cause to be transmitted, the necessary forms to the counsel-appointment program. Within 24 hours. Man: A magistrate found that I qualified for counsel, but the paperwork wasn’t forwarded for several weeks, and my initial lawyer was rubbish and never met with me, so I was stuck in jail for 252 days until the state finally dropped the case against me. I was never even charged! Fifth Circuit : The jail administrator enjoys qualified immunity for the (seemingly widespread) failure to forward the counsel-appointment forms to the folks who could, y’know, appoint counsel.
- Sixth Circuit : Forcing a compliant suspect to pee in his front yard when there were plenty of officers on hand to supervise a trip to the toilet is an obvious Fourth Amendment violation. No qualified immunity. Case undismissed. Dissent: At the Founding, public urination was probably not a crime in these circumstances.
- If you haven’t kept up with House of the Dragon, small-town Wisconsin politics is a fit substitute. To put this case in GRRM terms, when the Blacks take King’s Landing and purge the gov’t of any opposing Greens, is that a First Amendment violation? The Seven(th Circuit) : You’ll have to wait for the final season to find out; here, we’re just granting qualified immunity because our case law on firing policymakers over political differences is a mess.
August 21st Newsletter
- Man videorecords Waterbury, Conn. police station from public sidewalk, declines to show ID to officers. He’s arrested. (Prosecution is dropped over two years later.) Second Circuit : It was dusk and he didn’t answer officers’ questions, so there’s no 4A violation. And while it’s now clearly established that recording the police is 1A protected, qualified immunity. Concurrence: He wasn’t recording the police!
- Allegation: Grandmother is taken to off-the-books warehouse (the “Brave Cave”) and strip searched after Baton Rouge, La. officers find prescription drugs in her car and refuse to let her show them her prescriptions. District court : Which is clearly unconstitutional. No qualified immunity. Fifth Circuit (unpublished): To discovery this must go.
- Allegation: In 2021, Port Lavaca, Tex. officers arrest head shop owner and employee for selling illegal edibles. (Charges are dropped after officers are “unavailable to testify due to a credibility issue.”) Oops! Lab tests did indicate the presence of THC but not whether the concentration was high enough to render the products illegal, and the investigating officer was being just a tad imprecise when he swore otherwise. Fifth Circuit (per curiam, unpublished): Qualified immunity.
- Allegation : Saginaw County, Mich. officers call in sick en masse (“blue flu”) after an officer is fired for punching a handcuffed woman. In response, activists set up a table and chairs near police union building to engage officers in dialogue about police culture. Within minutes, officers falsely accuse them of trespassing and then tackle, tase, knee, and arrest the organizer, who’d tried to deescalate and then passively resisted cuffing. Sixth Circuit (unpublished): To a jury this must go. No qualified immunity. Dissent: The officers were actually pretty patient with this guy.
- Indiana prison officers give inmate a pair of rough rides; first, breaking his collarbone after leaving him unbuckled in prison van and slamming on the brakes. Then, right after a surgery, deliberately driving over bumps and laughing as he yelled out in pain. District court: Qualified immunity all around. Seventh Circuit : Actually, the first rough ride should go to a jury. Partial dissent: They both should!
- Seventh Circuit (over a dissent): It’s been clearly established since 1962 that holding a 14-year-old incommunicado for five days to force a confession out of him is unconstitutional. But this 14-year-old, who falsely confessed to murder in 1977, was only in custody for two days. And he got to see his dad for a few minutes. To a jury this cannot go. Denial of QI reversed.
- Azusa, Calif. officers beat, tase disturbed man, leaving him in a vegetative state. An eyewitness says the man wasn’t threatening and laid down on his stomach just before officers started kicking him. Officers: Plaintiffs didn’t timely disclose this witness. Strike his declaration! District court: No, we can just extend the discovery deadline. Ninth Circuit : Qualified immunity lets gov’t employees immediately appeal all kinds of things, but not this.
August 28th Newsletter
- Allegation: Woman peacefully protests fatal police shooting by grilling hot dogs and hamburgers outside Lafayette, La. mayor’s house. She is arrested for obstructing the roadway, which she wasn’t, and strip searched at jail. Unlawful retaliation for speech? Unconstitutional arrest without probable cause? Fifth Circuit : Qualified immunity. Dissent: Qualified immunity is made up and wrong, and also it doesn’t apply here.
- You could read this whole Eleventh Circuit opinion about Miami-Dade commissioners allegedly using police to settle personal and political scores and then firing the police chief, who, in his capacity as a private citizen, objected. Or you could “ctrl-f” for “Elvis,” “tight pants,” and “The Godfather,” which are not fun pop culture references but real things from the case. Qualified and legislative immunity for the commissioners denied!
The July QI Update
Brake Lights, Community, and Accountability Reform
Last month, AAQI was proud to be part of a community Brake Light Block Party alongside Black Lives Matter Springfield , CARE for Victims , Members of the Former Massey Commission, Team Edifye , and other local organizations.
The event aimed to help drivers stay safe, avoid unnecessary traffic stops, and strengthen relationships between community organizations and local residents while also educating about the harms of qualified immunity and promoting the work of the Illinois Accountability Coalition.
Hundreds of neighbors came together for free brake light repairs, food, preventative health screenings, family-friendly fun, and a conversation about accountability reform in Illinois.
AAQI is working in Illinois as a part of the Illinois Accountability Coalition, a statewide group of nonprofit organizations, impacted individuals, and community members united in support of statewide qualified immunity reform. The Illinois Accountability Act, introduced last session as SB 3699, would create a state-level legal pathway that prohibits qualified immunity as a defense to ensure victims can have their day in court when their rights are violated by a public official.
To learn more about the dangers of qualified immunity, how it limits rights enforcement, and why the community should support this legislation, visit our Illinois Accountability Coalition website or our broader AAQI website !
QI in the Courts
Each week, IJ’s Center for Judicial Engagement publishes a newsletter highlighting opinions by the Federal Courts, aptly called Short Circuit (it’s also a podcast ). AAQI highlights the QI-related stories from Short Circuit each month in our monthly email series: QI in the Courts. If you have not already, you can subscribe to the newsletter here to get the full list of opinion summaries each week.
July 3rd Newsletter
- Houston officer lies on no-knock warrant application, raids home of couple who are not drug dealers but are gun owners. Officers don’t wear body cams into the house; officers outside the house don’t activate their cams until the raid is underway or over. Five officers are shot, as many as four by friendly fire. Qualified immunity for the officer who shot husband and wife dead? District court: No, there are disputed facts . To a jury this must go. Fifth Circuit : Tragic. Harrowing. Reversed. We don’t second-guess officers in a gunfight.
- Without a court order, Mariemont, Ohio officers push their way into condo, evict septuagenarian who had lived there for years—at the behest of the recently deceased condo owner’s nephew. Yikes! The nephew wasn’t on the up and up. Sixth Circuit (over a dissent): Actively participating in an eviction without any legal basis violates the Fourth Amendment. No qualified immunity.
July 10th Newsletter
- Pretrial detainee at the Aiken County, S.C. jail develops a “grapefruit sized” lump on her head and files a series of grievances (“HUGE ABSCESS,” “KEEPS GETTING BIGGER,” “PLEASE HELP ME”) that result in not much action. Eventually, she’s hospitalized with a bone infection and severe sepsis, and part of her skull is removed. Fourth Circuit : No QI.
- Distressed man walks in and out of traffic, pleads for help, repeatedly pulls away from handcuffs. A Colorado Springs, Colo. paramedic tackles him and chokes him until he stops moving. Then the paramedic puts his full bodyweight down on the man’s head and neck for about 45 seconds until an officer gets him cuffed. He dies. Tenth Circuit (unpublished): Qualified immunity. After the cuffs were on, the paramedic let up.
July 17th Newsletter
- New Orleans police officer enters yard, shoots, kills 16-week-old puppy who was running toward him without growling, barking, etc. Jury: Shouldn’t have done that but qualified immunity. Also, the city’s policies were not to blame, but the city is liable to the bereaved owners. Fifth Circuit : New trial on municipal liability.
- Ninth Circuit (unpublished): Hitting a suspect in the face with a baton is deadly force, and a reasonable jury could find it was unreasonable in this case where the suspect had his hands raised and was obeying officer commands. Anyhow (over a dissent), qualified immunity.
- Two people allege that they were sexually abused by Pushmataha County, Okla. jailers. Tenth Circuit (2025): Though the Ninth Circuit presumes non-consent between guards and inmates, we don’t. Nevertheless, there are enough disputed facts to send this to a jury rather than grant qualified immunity. Tenth Circuit (2026): Though the sheriff’s willful disregard for criminal sexual conduct inside the jail is inexcusable, there is no municipal liability. Concurrence: We need to overturn our precedent and presume non-consent (in a case where the argument is advanced).
The June QI Update
Government Accountability in Alabama!
Our report, 50 Shades of Government Immunity , released in 2022, revealed just how difficult it is to hold government officials accountable under state law. Years later, little has changed. Only eight states have standalone civil rights statutes, just sixteen recognize damages claims directly under their constitutions, and immunity doctrines continue to block relief for many people whose rights have been violated.
Alabama is no exception. The state earns an F for government accountability. There is no state civil rights statute, no recognized damages remedy under the state constitution, and broad sovereign immunity protects the state, sheriffs, and many other government officials from suit. While some tort claims are permitted, sweeping exceptions and liability limits leave people in Alabama with few meaningful avenues to vindicate their rights.
QI in the Courts
Each week, IJ’s Center for Judicial Engagement publishes a newsletter highlighting opinions by the Federal Courts, aptly called Short Circuit (it’s also a podcast ). AAQI highlights the QI-related stories from Short Circuit each month in our monthly email series: QI in the Courts. If you have not already, you can subscribe to the newsletter here to get the full list of opinion summaries each week.
June 5th Newsletter
- Man dies after jumping from a highway overpass. Philadelphia police officer, in violation of department policy, uses his personal cell phone to photograph the dead man lying on the road. Then, in “a poor attempt at ‘humor,'” he sends it to several colleagues, one of whom posts it to social media. It is forwarded to the bereaved mother, who sues the officer. Third Circuit (unpublished): Qualified immunity. There is no clearly established right to control dissemination and exploitation of one’s close relatives’ death scene images. Dissent: Our history and traditions establish that it was so obviously wrong that he was on notice.
- New Orleans crime lab tech warns supervisors about safety and accuracy concerns with the lab’s drug testing. Supervisors, officers show up at the tech’s home to conduct a “wellness check” and insist that the tech accompany them to take a drug test (the very one whose accuracy he questioned). He demurs, the supervisors call their boss, who says the tech is “being ordered to come into work to take this test.” He’s searched, placed in the back of a cop car, and driven to take his blood test, where he resigns instead of being tested. Fourth Amendment violations? Fifth Circuit (2024): Qualified immunity for some, not all. Fifth Circuit (2026): No QI for the supervisors’ boss, who ordered officers to bring the tech in without a warrant or exigent circumstances. (Both officers faced internal discipline : one suspended, one fired.)
- Potential prison informant alleges detectives put him at risk by being too open about his potential cooperation against a fellow inmate. Seventh Circuit : But there’s no clearly established right against such risk if you weren’t actually attacked by another inmate. Instead, “the tradeoff between investigation and safety has been left to law enforcement agencies and the political process.” Qualified immunity.
June 12th Newsletter
- When a district court denies a defendant’s request for qualified immunity, the defendant gets a special right of interlocutory appeal (which can delay litigation for months). But what if the district court just doesn’t mention the request for qualified immunity at all? That triggers the same appeal right as a denial would, says the Fifth Circuit .
- Pro se Kansas prisoner: I was subject to excessive force during a medical emergency. Defendants: Qualified and sovereign immunity, please. District court: Happy to consider it, but please comply with the page limits for your motion. Defendants: No, we’d rather appeal. Tenth Circuit : Guys, official immunities may give gov’t defendants lots of chances for interlocutory appeals, but not just because you don’t want to follow the rules. Appeal dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.
June 19th Newsletter
- Though they are not in its path, Jacksonville, Ark. officers shoot, kill would-be thief driving truck away from them at low speed. Eighth Circuit : No QI. Nothing in the video blatantly contradicts the district court’s finding that there are factual disputes that can only be resolved by a jury.
June 26th Newsletter
- In response to several near-fatal overdoses, a Virginia prison institutes a new strip-search protocol—of inmates escorted to a nearly empty videoconference room, that they use one at a time, under video surveillance, that’s searched in between uses. An inmate strip searched 26 times in a month sues. Fourth Circuit : Even in prison, this looks like a Fourth Amendment violation. It’s nearly impossible to trade contraband in the room, and the policy was based on an unsubstantiated tip. But no need to make any law on that. Qualified immunity!
- In a refreshingly commonsense qualified-immunity opinion, the Fifth Circuit holds that, even if someone is suspected of serious crimes and is squirming around, if he’s already handcuffed and detained in a police car then it’s clearly unconstitutional to discharge high-velocity pepper spray at his face point-blank thereby blinding him in one eye.
- Mountain View, Colo. firefighter is deeply chagrined to learn that a new recruit has, for religious reasons, requested not to have the American flag emblazoned on his kit. The firefighter, who is also the union prez, proceeds to (it is said) act like a big jerk about it, and for that he is fired. Did it violate due process not to have a post-termination hearing? Tenth Circuit (unpublished): Who can say what process is due? Qualified immunity.
The May QI Update
Make Your Voice Heard!
Americans Against Qualified Immunity is bringing together voices from across the country to show that accountability under the law matters to people from all walks of life. Help us demonstrate the growing support for ending qualified immunity by adding your voice to the campaign.
We’re collecting short selfie videos from supporters across the country. Participants can submit either:
- A 30-second video sharing why they oppose qualified immunity, ending with: “That’s why I am an American against qualified immunity.”
- Or a simple video saying: “I am an American against qualified immunity.”
Videos should be filmed vertically, clear and well-lit, and participants must be 18 or older. Selected submissions may be featured on social media, campaign materials, and public awareness efforts.
Help put a human face on the fight for accountability by submitting your voice today.
QI in the Courts
Each week, IJ’s Center for Judicial Engagement publishes a newsletter highlighting opinions by the federal courts, aptly called Short Circuit (it’s also a podcast ). AAQI highlights the QI-related stories from Short Circuit each month in our monthly email series: QI in the Courts. If you have not already, you can subscribe to the newsletter here to get the full list of opinion summaries each week.
May 1st Newsletter
- Allegation: During an early COVID-era “lockdown,” Columbia, S.C. cop sees a teenager strolling down a sidewalk. He takes off after the cop approaches. Cop repeatedly yells for the kid to stop and sees he has a firearm, although it’s not pointed at anyone. Cop fires 9 times and it ends with a fatal forehead shot. Fourth Circuit : It’s clearly established you can’t use deadly force when a fleeing suspect poses no immediate threat. No qualified immunity.
- Allegation: Man suffering from a medical episode, and who relies on a prosthetic leg, breaks into a Chesterfield County, Va. used car dealership. Police arrive and he curls up in the fetal position. An officer with a dog named “Kona” allows Kona to savagely attack the man, causing severe damage to his prosthetic leg—and real body parts as well. Police: But we gave some warnings. District court: In that case, qualified immunity. Fourth Circuit : What does “fetal position” mean to you? Reversed. Dissent: The case the majority relies on concerns a baseball bat, not a dog.
May 15th Newsletter
- Michigan man, arrested following domestic disturbance, admits to having ingested several pills of unknown identity. He’s taken to the emergency room, which medically clears him for incarceration. While in pre-trial detention, he becomes lethargic and vomits. At some point in the early morning hours, he dies from what is later determined to be an overdose of antidepressants. Deliberate indifference? Sixth Circuit : Denial of qualified immunity reversed. He may have been unwell, but his need for emergency medical care was not so obvious that a layperson can be held liable.
May 29th Newsletter
- Madison, Wisc. police hear loud bangs and see drunk man (who is thought to own firearms) go inside home. SWAT surrounds the house. But the man does not respond, and during five-hour impasse there are no more gunshot-like noises. They enter the house and shoot him with foam bullets, including after he’d come downstairs empty handed and as officers gave conflicting commands. (No shell casings are found, and a jury acquits him of being a felon in possession.) Seventh Circuit : A jury could find some constitutional violations here, but qualified immunity. Concurrence: “[T]he day has come when the doctrine’s privilege has nearly eclipsed the Constitution’s guarantees.”
- Two DeKalb County, Ga. officers investigating stolen vehicle knock on a house’s front door, enter when it swings open. They go upstairs, find a man sitting in his bed who throws a phone at them. One officer shoots a half dozen times, killing the man. He was unarmed. (The shooting officer was fired and accepted a plea deal for involuntary manslaughter.) The man’s family sues for Fourth Amendment violations. The shooting officer invokes qualified immunity and appeals his loss to the Eleventh Circuit. Family: The court shouldn’t even entertain the appeal because the issues are all factual and thus ought to be hashed out at trial. Eleventh Circuit (unpublished): Nope, the issues are legal, so we’re going to address them in the normal course. File your brief.
The April QI Update
Americans Against Qualified Immunity: Share Your Voice
Qualified immunity makes it extraordinarily difficult to hold government officials accountable when constitutional rights are violated. Americans Against Qualified Immunity is launching a people-powered social media campaign to show that accountability under the law matters to Americans from all walks of life.
We’re collecting short selfie videos from supporters across the country. Participants can submit a 30-second video sharing why they oppose qualified immunity, ending with: “That’s why I am an American against qualified immunity.”
Or participants can submit a simple video saying: “I am an American against qualified immunity.”
Videos should be filmed vertically, clear and well-lit, and participants must be 18 or older. Selected submissions may be featured on social media, campaign materials, and public awareness efforts.
Help put a human face on the fight for accountability by submitting your voice today.
QI in the Courts
Each week, IJ’s Center for Judicial Engagement publishes Short Circuit —a newsletter and podcast that highlights notable federal court opinions. Each month, AAQI curates QI-related stories from Short Circuit and brings them to you here.
April 3rd Newsletter
- A Texas pretrial detainee gave birth alone in her cell, and the baby died. The jail’s medical director never read an email about her symptoms. Fifth Circuit : Qualified immunity.
- After a St. Louis employee reported corruption at a city tow lot, a jury found she was fired in violation of the First Amendment. Eighth Circuit : The defendant forfeited the qualified immunity defense.
- Allegation: A Tulsa officer fatally shot a nonthreatening man who had his hands raised. Tenth Circuit : Reversed a grant of qualified immunity.
- An Atlanta officer says superiors changed his longtime flexible schedule after he reported special treatment for a former mayor’s grandson. Eleventh Circuit : A jury could find retaliation, so that claim may proceed.
- Victory! A federal court found a Parksley, Virginia, councilman violated the Fourth Amendment by cutting a food truck’s water pipe and denied him qualified immunity .
April 10th Newsletter
After U.S. Marshals fatally shot a man during a raid in Atlanta, Georgia indicted the officers. Eleventh Circuit : It lacked jurisdiction over the state’s appeal seeking a limited remand to file a new indictment. In separate civil litigation, his mother’s claims survived qualified immunity in 2022 but ultimately failed in 2024 .
April 17th Newsletter
- A Milwaukee bailiff improperly told jurors they could not deadlock; the defendant’s conviction was overturned. Seventh Circuit : It lacked jurisdiction to decide whether another bailiff was entitled to qualified immunity.
- Police used a location-tracking app to search a St. Louis County home for stolen AirPods. The AirPods were outside in the street, and the residents were unconnected to the crime. Eighth Circuit : Qualified immunity.
April 24th Newsletter
During the 2020 protests, a Denver officer shot a nonthreatening protester with a pepperball without warning or cause. A jury found a Fourth Amendment violation. Tenth Circuit : No qualified immunity.
The March QI Update
How Easy Is It to Sue the Government When It Violates Your Rights?
In 2022, our report 50 Shades of Government Immunity mapped the maze people face when bringing civil rights claims under state law. Even years later, one thing hasn’t changed: holding government officials accountable is still far harder than it should be.
The findings remain striking. Only eight states have standalone civil rights statutes—and even those are often weakened by layers of immunity. Just sixteen states allow claims directly under their constitutions, but confusing caselaw frequently shuts those cases down. And while most states technically permit tort claims against government officials, the reality is a patchwork of exceptions that makes winning nearly impossible.
The result? For many Americans, their rights exist more on paper than in practice. If we’re serious about ending qualified immunity and restoring civil rights, state-level reform can’t be overlooked. This report shows just how much work remains.
QI in the Courts
Each week, IJ’s Center for Judicial Engagement publishes Short Circuit —a newsletter and podcast that highlights notable federal court opinions. Each month, AAQI curates QI-related stories from Short Circuit and brings them to you here.
March 6th Newsletter
Fourth Circuit : A jury might have a look at the video of an Alleghany County, Va. deputy punching a suspect in the face 12 times—breaking his jaw, his orbital bone, and causing a brain bleed—and think that was unreasonable. No qualified immunity.
March 13th Newsletter
- Trigger-happy residents of Canton, Ohio have the habit of shooting firearms into the air to celebrate the New Year. As a police officer responds to the sound of gunfire shortly after midnight, he sees a man firing some 39 rounds into the air. The officer gets spooked and shoots the man dead. His widow sues. Sixth Circuit : The case must go to a jury.
- Allegation : Escambia County, Fla. cops don’t take required steps to verify missing-child report before heading to a home where the child might be found. Eleventh Circuit : No qualified immunity for gratuitous force and rummaging through drawers.
- The Ninth Circuit declined to reconsider its denial of qualified immunity involving a North Las Vegas officer who jumped a backyard fence while searching for a suspect.
March 20th Newsletter
During “reception and evaluation” period, all new inmates entering South Carolina prisons are confined to their cells nearly 24/7 for months. Fourth Circuit : No qualified immunity for prison staffers whose adherence to the policy caused severe suffering.
March 27th Newsletter
- Echols County, Ga. school officials allegedly retaliated against and fired a Black teacher on a pretext. Eleventh Circuit : No qualified immunity.
- Atlanta officer tases fleeing sexagenarian who posed no threat. Eleventh Circuit : Affirmed.
- Victory! Escambia County, Ala.’s district attorney must answer for a bogus investigation targeting school board members and journalists.
The February QI Update
Welcome to this month’s QI Update, a monthly roundup of key stories, cases, and developments shaping the fight against qualified immunity!
In Case You Missed It:
Watch This Episode of Beyond the Brief
Last month we highlighted a must-watch episode of the Institute for Justice’s Beyond the Brief : “Ending Qualified Immunity Will Improve Policing.” If you didn’t get a chance to watch it, now’s the perfect time.
In this conversation, retired LAPD lieutenant Jeff Wenniger , who served more than 30 years in law enforcement, joins IJ Senior Attorney Patrick Jaicomo to discuss what real accountability in policing looks like—for both the public and police officers themselves.
They explore why stronger accountability can actually improve policing, what many officers think about qualified immunity, and how ending unjust legal protections can help build trust between communities and law enforcement.
Watch the episode—and please share it with your networks!
QI in the Courts
Each week, IJ’s Center for Judicial Engagement publishes Short Circuit —a newsletter and podcast that highlights notable federal court opinions. Each month, AAQI curates QI-related stories from Short Circuit and brings them to you here.
If you would like to receive all of the opinion summaries each week, sign up here for the full Short Circuit newsletter.
February 6th Newsletter
- Arlington, Tex. police cadet suffers a fatal cardiac arrest during a self-defense training exercise at the academy. His wife sues the city and all the officers present, alleging violations of the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments. Fifth Circuit : Qualified immunity.
February 13th Newsletter
- Kentucky woman calls 911 on her son after a dispute involving gasoline and a lighter. Police arrive and tase the man almost immediately. Sixth Circuit : Qualified immunity.
- Opa-Locka, Fla. man experiences an episode of erratic behavior. Officers allegedly tase, punch, and drag him while attempting to handcuff him. Eleventh Circuit : No qualified immunity for the most punch- and taser-happy officers.
February 20th Newsletter
- North Carolina prisoner is severely injured after being attacked by a dangerous inmate who should have been separated from the general prison population. Fourth Circuit : Enough evidence to proceed to trial on deliberate indifference claims.
- Two Cleveland police officers respond to a call about an armed man. One officer accidentally shoots his partner. Sixth Circuit : Qualified immunity.
February 27th Newsletter
- Victory! A federal court rejected a mayor and police chief’s invocation of qualified immunity after retaliatory arrests targeting a government critic. Learn more .
- Fifth Circuit grants qualified immunity after officers relied on information obtained from an allegedly unconstitutional cellphone search.
- Tenth Circuit : No qualified immunity for officers who used sweeping warrants to search protest-related digital data.
The January QI Update
Welcome to this month’s QI Update, a monthly roundup of key stories, cases, and developments shaping the fight against qualified immunity!
A Must-Watch:
“Ending Qualified Immunity Will Improve Policing”
In a recent episode of the Institute for Justice’s Beyond the Brief , a critical question takes center stage: What does real accountability in policing look like—for both the public and police officers themselves?
The episode features Jeff Wenniger, a retired LAPD lieutenant with more than 30 years in law enforcement, who now advocates for rethinking policing around trust, integrity, and genuine community partnership.
He’s joined by IJ Senior Attorney Patrick Jaicomo, who leads IJ’s efforts to dismantle qualified immunity and other legal doctrines that shield government officials from accountability.
Together, they discuss why greater accountability makes policing stronger, what many officers actually think about qualified immunity, and how ending unjust legal protections can improve policing for everyone.
QI in the Courts
Each week, IJ’s Center for Judicial Engagement publishes Short Circuit—a newsletter and podcast that highlights notable federal court opinions. Each month, AAQI curates QI-related stories from Short Circuit and brings them to you here.
January 2nd Newsletter
- New on the Short Circuit podcast: Find out what it’s like to litigate for people behind bars—including when they overcome qualified immunity.
- For weeks, staff at a secure, state-run Norwich, N.Y. facility for people with severe disabilities ignore man’s increasingly worrisome signs of heart disease, as well as his mother’s pleas to take him to a hospital. Per an expert, his death felt like drowning. Facility: Ah, but he was admitted voluntarily, so we didn’t have a constitutional duty of care to him. Second Circuit: Grant of qualified immunity reversed. To trial this must go.
January 9th Newsletter
- New on the Short Circuit podcast: What do Joan of Arc’s trial and qualified immunity have to do with each other? IJ’s Tahmineh Dehbozorgi explains.
- Baltimore SWAT officer shoots mentally ill veteran in the back, killing him. Officer: Because he was running at me with a machete. Fourth Circuit: Denial of QI affirmed. To trial this must go.
- Phoenix police encounter man behaving erratically. They subdue him and place him in a “RIPP” restraint, effectively hogtying him. After grunting, gasping, and falling limp, the man is placed facedown in the back of a patrol car. Shortly thereafter, he dies. His estate sues. Ninth Circuit: No qualified immunity.
January 23rd Newsletter
- Woman calls her mother to say that a man—her foe in a years-long legal dispute—was at her Kansas City, Kan. house, trying to kill her and her husband. Police arrive, find the couple shot to death. They set their sights on the woman’s foe. Yet no evidence linked him to the deaths, either at his home or theirs. He’s convicted anyway. A decade later, the state finally gets around to testing gunshot residue swabs, which reveal gunshot residue on the woman’s hand. Further investigation uncovers that a snitch’s testimony was bogus and a boatload of exculpatory evidence was missing from the case files. He’s released—and dies just a few months later. Tenth Circuit: No qualified immunity for the two lead investigators.
January 30th Newsletter
- Allegation: Reynoldsburg, Ohio officer grabs woman as she opens front door without giving her a chance to comply with order to step outside. When she tenses up and pulls back, he performs a takedown maneuver that results in injuries requiring four surgeries. District court: Could be excessive force. Sixth Circuit: Qualified immunity.
- During COVID-19 lockdowns in a California prison, one prisoner is forced to stay either in his cell or in a crowded work area with about 130 other inmates. He is denied outdoor recreation time. Ninth Circuit: And there’s no qualified immunity for the warden.
- Allegation: Macon County, Ala. deputy sheriff swings by the office while off duty, gets intoxicated, speeds homeward in his police truck, sans lights, and kills another driver. A violation of the driver’s due-process rights? Eleventh Circuit: We’re going to assume that the deputy was acting under color of state law. We’re also going to assume that the deputy’s conduct “shocked the conscience.” But he gets qualified immunity even so.
Best,
The AAQI team